Runners often carry a few assumptions about shoe shopping that sound reasonable but don’t hold up once you look at what actually affects comfort and injury risk.
Myth: a well-known brand guarantees a good fit
Reality: fit varies enormously between models from the same brand, let alone between different brands. A shoe that works well for one person can feel completely wrong for another with a different foot shape, regardless of how popular the brand is.
Myth: the more cushioning, the better
Reality: cushioning needs vary by runner, running style, and surface. Heavily cushioned shoes suit some people well and leave others feeling unstable or disconnected from the ground, particularly on uneven terrain.
Myth: you should buy shoes a half size smaller for a snug fit
Reality: feet swell slightly during running and throughout the day, so shoes that feel exactly snug at the store often feel too tight an hour into a longer run. A little extra room in the toe box is generally more comfortable than a snug fit meant to feel precise.
Myth: one pair should last until it visibly falls apart
Reality: cushioning and support break down internally well before a shoe looks worn out externally, which means relying purely on appearance to judge replacement timing often means running in shoes that have already lost much of their support.
Trying shoes on later in the day, walking and jogging briefly in-store, and paying attention to how a shoe actually feels matters more than any label on the box.
